Blog

What I admire about the anti-capitalist left is their ability to present their ideas as somehow "unorthodox" and "anti-mainstream", when they are clearly nothing of the sort. Go to any high street bookstore, and you will find that the politics section consists of little else but the tomes of Naomi Klein, Noam Chomsky, Russell Brand, Owen Jones, Ha-Joon Chang, George Monbiot and the other usual suspects. If that is a "neoliberal hegemony", I dread to think what a left-wing hegemony would look like.

Still, I am amazed by how the British left has managed to convince themselves that Syriza somehow represented a break with "neoliberal politics" in Greece. According to Zoe Williams, what Syriza and other far-left parties in Europe have in common "is that they reject the prevailing economic verities”. Meanwhile, Owen Jones has trumpeted that “Outside the Greek finance ministry are cleaners who used to work there […] There is a real sense that maybe – just maybe – the likes of these sacked middle-aged cleaners could be the new masters now.” He adds: “No wonder so many [European] leftists [...] travelled to Athens for this moment. For many of them, neoliberalist triumphalism is all they have ever known.”

Yet after three and a half decades of economic statism and hyperinterventionism, how exactly is a party that stands for economic statism and hyperinterventionism a "break" with anything? Ever since the PASOK victory of 1981, Greek politics has been Fifty Shades of Red, and Syriza merely represents a more glaring shade in this spectrum.

The seeds of the current crisis were sown in the 1980s, when PASOK built up a huge client state, buying the support of various electoral groups through selective subsidies and favours. Other parties soon joined them in this endeavour, turning Greek politics into a bidding war, and the Greek state into a patronage machine. Between the late 1970s and the early 1990s, government revenue surged from under 25 per cent of GDP to over 35 per cent, but client states are expensive to maintain, and government favours fuel demand for more government favours. So the money was never enough, and the shortfall was made up by borrowing and printing more of it. Government debt increased from less than 20 per cent of GDP to more than 100 per cent, and inflation jumped from less than 5 per cent to more than 10 per cent, while growth largely stalled.

The Greek economy had become a rent-seeking economy, in which economic activity is not about creating wealth, but about extracting wealth from others through the political process. If you’re afraid of dog-eat-dog capitalism, you haven’t seen dog-eat-dog socialism yet.

A particularly popular form of favouritism has been to restrict entry into various professions. This benefits incumbents, because it wards off competitors, and drives up the value of their licence. But their gains come at the expense of consumers and of would-be entrants. Every country has some protected sectors, and as long as there aren’t that many of them, it does not matter hugely. But when over a hundred professions are closed off, as is the case in Greece, the cost to consumers becomes unbearable, even before taking into account the decline in labour mobility and productivity.

At the same time, the economic policy fundamentals – essentially, the rule of law and the quality of institutions – have been undermined, or at least utterly neglected. In the World Bank’s "Ease of Doing Business" rankings, Greece ranks 155th out of 189 countries in the crucial “enforcing contracts” category, just a few places above Zimbabwe and Sudan. In the "registering property" category, Greece comes out 116th, behind Pakistan, Ethiopia and Cambodia. The Fraser Institute’s "Economic Freedom" index shows a similar picture. In all-important categories like "judicial independence", "impartial courts", "protection of property rights" or "reliability of the police", Greece looks more similar to Latin American than to the rest of Europe.

Presumably, a correction would eventually have been inevitable. But the country’s ill-advised admission into the Eurozone flooded it with cheap credit, which led to a fake boom that magnified the worst elements of Greek politics.

Unfortunately, the time for good solutions has now expired. The least bad solution would be a not-too-disorderly exit from the Eurozone, a return to the Drachma and effectively a sharp devaluation, followed by a partial or even full sovereign default. That, of course, would mean more austerity, not less.

Greek wages and prices would fall steeply in real terms, and the Greek government would be locked out of capital markets for the foreseeable future. But the Greek economy would price itself back into international markets, and structural reforms might finally become feasible if they could no longer be presented as an imposition from you-know-who. Greece’s political class would run out of excuses, and that can only be a good thing. 

 

Dr Kristian Niemietz is the IEA’s Senior Research Fellow. This article was first published by The Independent

Comments (1)
Everything that Kristian writes may well be true; but it is hard not to feel some sympathy for the current Greek government. I seem to remember that the rulers of the eurozone chose to ignore the terms of the Stability and Growth Pact when it suited them. In the eurozone if you don't trust the 'government' you can't throw the rascals out from time to time -- all you can do is quit yourself. That is what Greece should now do (and, of course, what the UK should now do with respect to the European Union).

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Type the characters you see in this picture. (verify using audio)
Type the characters you see in the picture above; if you can't read them, submit the form and a new image will be generated. Not case sensitive.

As in all IEA publications, the views expressed in this blog are those of the authors and not those of the Institute (which has no corporate view), its managing trustees, Academic Advisory Council or senior staff.

Previous blog posts

Search

Philip Booth
1 July 2015
comments

In Part 1 of this post, I looked at the way international financial regulation encouraged complexity and regulatory capture. In this part, I look at the problems of herd behaviour and the making of...
Ryan Bourne
30 June 2015
21 comments

Nothing is certain in life but death and the annual claim that the poorest fifth of households pay the highest proportion of their incomes in taxes. Each year, when the ONS publishes its ‘...
Jesús Huerta de Soto and Philipp Bagus
29 June 2015
1 comment

The ECB has finally launched its own open-ended Quantitative Easing (QE) planning to buy securities worth of €1.1tr euros. This unprecedented move requires a convincing justification. One...
Kristian Niemietz
26 June 2015
comments

As an undergraduate student, I spent an Erasmus semester in a small town in Spain. During a flat viewing, the landlady who showed me around pointed at the microwave in the kitchen, and said: ‘...
Ryan Bourne
25 June 2015
comments

Child poverty (measured as children living in a household below 60 per cent of median income) has remained unchanged. But in recent days, as it was expected to have risen, it has been said the...
Christopher Snowdon
25 June 2015
1 comment

In a classic Beyond the Fringe sketch, Peter Cook is a cult leader sat atop a mountain awaiting the end of the world. When the predicted apocalypse fails to arrive, he turns to his followers and says...
Philip Booth
24 June 2015
1 comment

In the last 30 years there has been a huge movement towards the internationalisation of financial regulation. This manifests itself at the EU level but also more widely. If you were to use a random...
Ryan Bourne
23 June 2015
3 comments

Bruce Springsteen may have been “Born in the USA”, but he says he’d prefer the US to be more like Sweden. With its generous welfare state, many hold up the Swedes, and other...
Ryan Bourne
22 June 2015
3 comments

History doesn’t repeat itself, but it does rhyme. On 12 June, 79 economists wrote to the Guardian condemning George Osborne’s plans to run budget surpluses “in good times...
Philip Booth
19 June 2015
4 comments

Pope Francis’ encyclical, ‘Laudato si’, is an important contribution to the theology and morality of the earth’s ecology in the context of a holistic conception of the human...
Diego Zuluaga Laguna
17 June 2015
comments

If healthcare in the 20th century was characterised by the successful eradication and containment of communicable diseases – from TB and smallpox to diphtheria, poliomyelitis and influenza...
Ryan Bourne
17 June 2015
19 comments

An unusual alliance has in recent times lined up to support a significant increase in the minimum wage to the so-called ‘Living Wage’. One argument heard by proponents on both left and...
Kristian Niemietz
16 June 2015
comments

In the UK, people who support a pluralistic, competitive and consumer-driven healthcare system often believe that theirs is a lost cause. They argue that the public’s commitment to the NHS is...
Philip Booth
15 June 2015
2 comments

On 12th June, the Guardian published a letter from 79 economists, including David Blanchflower, Thomas Piketty, Mariana Mazzucato and Ha-Joon Chang. The 79 argue that George Osborne’s proposals...
Len Shackleton
12 June 2015
1 comment

The government’s attempts to reduce immigration are not succeeding. In a piece of classic displacement activity, it now seems determined to impose ever more irksome obligations on business....
Peter Ainsworth
11 June 2015
comments

The current system of financing higher education is stuck in a rut. It does not work particularly well for anybody: A lot of students end up saddled with debt; large amounts of debt have to be...
Christopher Snowdon
10 June 2015
4 comments

Five years ago, in May 2010, I published The Spirit Level Delusion in response to Richard Wilkinson and Kate Pickett's book The Spirit Level which was being widely read at the time. Using similar...
Ryan Bourne
9 June 2015
comments

The Living Wage Foundation – which lobbies employers to pay £9.15 an hour in London and £7.85 elsewhere – has never called for statutory implementation of its cause. It...
Lawrence H. Summers
8 June 2015
1 comment

In many respects, Thomas Piketty’s Capital in the Twenty-First Century embodies the virtues that we all would like to see but find too infrequently in the work of academic economists. It is...