Following the release of the McNulty Review, Dr Richard Wellings, Deputy Editorial Director at the Institute of Economic Affairs, says that the review fails to address the structural errors that exist in the rail industry.
“The McNulty review fails to tackle the fundamental problems facing Britain’s railways. Even if its proposals are enacted, gross inefficiencies will remain and taxpayers will still find themselves funding vast subsidies.
“As long as Network Rail and other individual railway firms remain in receipt of taxpayer-funded subsidies, there will be little incentive to drive down costs and to provide a more efficient service. It is right that passengers should pay a greater proportion of the cost of the services they use; but it is also right that taxpayers should not be forced to pay for services that are grossly inefficient and are used by only a small proportion of the population. Allowing rail operators to own the infrastructure could transform Britain’s rail network.
“The government must stop tweaking with a fundamentally flawed model and instead unshackle the railways, and the railway operators, from the dead hand of state control.”