Lifestyle Economics Blog

Last night we learned that the government plans to change the law to ensure that cigarettes are sold in plain packages. The ostensible goal of reducing the number of smokers may be well-intentioned, but in practice this will be a policy with a negligible health impact and extremely worrying repercussions for black market activity.

International evidence from Australia – the only country to introduce plain packaging so far – shows that there has been no acceleration in the decline in adult smoking, while youth smoking appears to have risen. Public health campaigners assume that people start smoking as a result of seeing logos and colour schemes. This does not bear up to scrutiny; illegal tobacco now makes up 14.3 per cent of the Australian market and costs the government $1.2 billion. This is a shockingly large black market for an island continent that has no land borders.

Nearer to home, counterfeiting is already a substantial and growing issue, with imitation tobacco accounting for 65 per cent of cigarettes seized within the EU. Bear in mind there are over 200 different brands available – when there is just one standardised format, packets will become much easier to replicate. Counterfeit cigarettes often contain dangerous ingredients and can cause serious health issues, as well as significant losses to the Treasury.

Ultimately it is a product’s price, not colourful images, that its sales. Plain packaging may hit the profitability of premium brands but will do nothing to reduce smoking prevalence. By imposing standardised packaging, premium brands will see a fall in their profit as people shift towards buying cheaper brands, as has been the case in Australia. Although sales of cigarettes have been seen to fall, overall consumption of tobacco has not.

Preventing children from taking up smoking is a noble goal, but if the government is concerned about children smoking then they should focus on education and the enforcement of existing laws. Cracking down on retailers selling to children and a hardening of punishment for proxy buying would be much more effective ways of achieving this, rather than curtailing both the rights of consumers of a legal product and basic free-market principles.

At the very least the government should have seriously evaluated both the effect of plain packaging in Australia over a longer period, as well as the effects of British initiatives such as graphic tobacco health warnings and the display ban. Rushing through plain packaging legislation will mean we will never be able to meaningfully assess the impact of various strategies.

Plain packaging is not a sensible health policy. It will be a huge inconvenience to retailers, it will bolster the black market, and it is quite clearly based on spurious evidence. It is unfortunate that the government is putting politics above good policy.

 

This article first appeared on Conservative Home.

Search

Ryan Bourne
30 January 2014
It’s often said that modern day politicians lack conviction – that is, they are afraid of expressing their firmly held beliefs. This is not universally true, of course. But one of the...
Christopher Snowdon
7 January 2014
Ed Miliband’s pledge to crack down on the ‘crack cocaine of gambling’ is a significant moment in the extraordinary moral panic over fixed-odds betting terminals (FOBTs). Last...
Christopher Snowdon
14 October 2013
The poorest twenty per cent of households in Britain spend an average of £1,286 per year on ‘sin taxes’, including betting taxes, vehicle excise duty, air passenger duty, ‘...
Christopher Snowdon
4 September 2013
Many 'public health' policies aimed at reducing harmful alcohol use, such as minimum pricing, are underpinned by a belief in the Total Consumption Model. This model—also known as the...
Christopher Snowdon
1 August 2013
In 2010, a piece of research was published by Policy Exchange, a think tank, which managed to lodge one "fact" into the public's consciousness which has persisted every since. Namely,...
Christopher Snowdon
12 July 2013
So it's official. Neither the UK government nor the European Parliament will be legislating to put tobacco in plain packaging. It looks very likely that minimum pricing for alcohol will also be...
e-cigarettes, snus, harm reduction
Christopher Snowdon
11 July 2013
Are free markets incompatible with good health? To hear some of the rhetoric that comes from the medical establishment, you might think so. If the solution to every problem involves banning...
Barrie M. Craven, Michael L. Marlow and Alden F. Shiers
27 June 2013
Excessive alcohol consumption is associated with many deleterious effects on individual health.  Its negative impact on wider society includes crime (including domestic violence), drunk driving...
Christopher Snowdon
12 June 2013
It is brave for a lobby group that has a long track record of using dodgy surveys, junk science and misleading press releases to release a report entitled Stick To The Facts, but that is what state...
Christopher Snowdon
28 May 2013
Plain packaging for tobacco appears to have been rejected by the UK's Coalition government, just as it was rejected by the previous Labour government, but the idea continues to appeal to...
Christopher Snowdon
25 May 2013
  The negative consequences of putting 'sin taxes' on products when demand is inelastic are well known. Almost invariably, they hurt the poor more than the rich. They encourage black...
Christopher Snowdon
7 May 2013
This morning I was on the radio discussing electronic cigarettes in response to a headteacher banning their use at Blatchington Mill School, East Sussex (listen from 12 minutes in). The school has...
Christopher Snowdon
24 April 2013
More than fifty years have passed since bookmakers and casinos were legalised in Britain, but gambling remains at least partially taboo in some quarters. Few now remember the concerns raised about...

Invest in the IEA. We are the catalyst for changing consensus and influencing public debate.

Donate now

Thank you for
your support

Subscribe to
publications

Subscribe

eNEWSLETTER